Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi has issued a pointed warning to Prime Minister’s Adviser Rana Sanaullah, signalling growing tensions over the debate surrounding new provinces. Although Naqvi did not mention Sanaullah by name, his remarks suggested a direct response to the adviser’s recent criticism.
Speaking informally to journalists in Lahore on Sunday, Naqvi said he had patiently listened to Sanaullah’s comments for two-and-a-half years. However, he warned that his response could leave the minister unable to show his face. He also accused Sanaullah of making remarks about him to gain television exposure.
The exchange reflects growing differences within the ruling coalition over the proposed creation of new provinces. Moreover, disagreements have emerged over the economic forum where Naqvi initially raised the issue and the business figures involved in those discussions.
Sanaullah Questions Naqvi’s Role in New Provinces Debate
During a recent television interview, Sanaullah said the discussion about creating new provinces had become complicated following Naqvi’s remarks at an economic forum.
He questioned the involvement of certain businessmen from Karachi and Punjab who attended the gathering. According to Sanaullah, some business figures had repeatedly approached successive governments and army chiefs, presenting themselves as potential saviours of the country.
However, Sanaullah clarified that his criticism did not target the entire business community. He acknowledged that many businesspeople were patriotic citizens who contributed to Pakistan’s economy beyond political interests.
Nevertheless, he alleged that certain individuals had questionable involvement in both business and politics.
Sanaullah maintained that discussing new provinces at an economic forum was not inherently wrong. However, he argued that the conversation had become mixed with wider political controversies.
These included claims about the collapse of the existing governance system and criticism of the prime minister and politicians.
Bilawal’s Remarks Add Another Dimension to the Debate
Sanaullah also criticised PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari for introducing other political issues into the discussion.
These included constitutional amendments, elections, reserved seats and Naqvi’s position as chairman of the Pakistan Cricket Board.
He particularly questioned Bilawal’s remarks about Karachi potentially descending into bloodshed. According to Sanaullah, such comments were unnecessary and distracted attention from the central discussion about new provinces.
Furthermore, Sanaullah suggested that President Asif Ali Zardari should intervene to prevent disagreements from spreading into other political matters.
He urged the president to bring Naqvi and Bilawal together and advise them to resolve their differences. Both politicians should remain free to support or oppose new provinces without derailing the broader discussion.
Sanaullah also highlighted the close relationship between the two politicians and President Zardari. He noted that the president referred to the interior minister as his ‘son’.
Naqvi Defends Businessmen Who Attended Economic Forum
Responding to Sanaullah’s criticism, Naqvi defended the businessmen who participated in the economic forum.
He described them as respectable Pakistani citizens and among the country’s highest taxpayers. Additionally, he said some had previously served as presidents and office-bearers of federal and city-level chambers of commerce.
Naqvi questioned why political parties accepted financial contributions from these individuals during election campaigns if they considered them unsuitable.
“If these businessmen are so bad, why do political parties take billions of rupees from them in the name of party funds during every election?” he asked.
His response added another dimension to the disagreement, shifting attention towards the relationship between political parties and business figures.
Why Are Naqvi and Sanaullah Disagreeing Over New Provinces?
The latest exchange follows several months of differences over Naqvi’s support for creating additional administrative units.
At the Pakistan Economic Summit in Islamabad in late July, Naqvi described the existing governance system as having “collapsed”. He also called for fundamental reforms, including the creation of new administrative units.
Later, he maintained that the public should determine the future of the proposed provinces. He also said he would continue supporting the idea, regardless of whether he remained in office.
However, Sanaullah has repeatedly distanced the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) from Naqvi’s position.
He has argued that creating new provinces involves major constitutional questions. Therefore, the matter requires parliamentary debate, political consultation and consideration by the federal cabinet.
In September, Sanaullah clarified that the PML-N had not reached a final position. He also confirmed that no formal proposal had been presented to the federal cabinet or parliament.
Sanaullah Says Parliament Must Decide on New Provinces
Reiterating his position on Saturday, Sanaullah said parliament would ultimately determine the matter through debate.
He maintained that every political party should have an opportunity to present its position. Moreover, he acknowledged that public demand could support the creation of additional provinces.
However, he stressed that any decision must follow the constitutional process.
Sanaullah also explained that the PML-N would finalise its stance after consulting party leadership and workers. These consultations would extend to district and union-council levels.
With Naqvi and Sanaullah expressing differing positions, the debate over new provinces continues to expose disagreements within the ruling coalition. Meanwhile, Naqvi’s latest warning has brought their differences into sharper public focus.
For the latest updates, visit and follow The Truth International website (www.thetruthinternational.com) and subscribe to the YouTube Channel.
