Renowned Pakistani writer Umera Ahmed has clarified that writers do not make casting decisions after a viewer criticised Mehwish Hayat’s role in the drama Rutba. The discussion began on social media platform X, where a viewer questioned Mehwish’s pairing with younger co-stars. The criticism also included a dismissive reference to the actress as an “aunty.”
Responding to the comments, Umera explained that casting falls outside a writer’s responsibilities.
“Choosing and selecting artists for any role is not done by writer. Thank you.”
Umera Ahmed Separates Writing From Casting
Umera’s brief response highlighted the different responsibilities involved in television production. While writers develop stories and characters, casting decisions are handled separately by the production team.
Her clarification came amid online debate over Mehwish’s inclusion in Rutba. Some viewers questioned the age dynamics between the actress and her younger co-stars.
However, Umera did not directly address the criticism of Mehwish’s age or performance. Instead, she focused on clarifying who selects actors for roles.
Mehwish Hayat Plays Shehnaz in ‘Rutba’
Written by Umera Ahmed and directed by Haseeb Hassan, Rutba combines crime, suspense and romance.
The drama follows Hadi, a principled police officer played by Talha Chahour. His commitment to justice brings him into conflict with influential figures.
Mehwish plays Shehnaz, also known as Shelly, a sharp-witted character connected to the drama’s central storyline. Zahid Ahmed plays Meer, while Hiba Bukhari appears as Mahnoor.
The series explores themes of power, ambition, corruption and personal relationships. Its cast and storyline have attracted discussion since the drama’s launch.
Casting Debate Draws Attention Online
The exchange has renewed discussion about the responsibilities of writers, directors and producers in television dramas. It also reflects how casting choices can become a subject of public debate.
Umera’s response made one point clear: writers should not automatically be held responsible for selecting actors. Meanwhile, viewers continue to discuss the casting and character dynamics in Rutba.
For the latest updates, visit and follow The Truth International website (www.thetruthinternational.com) and subscribe to the YouTube Channel.
