The Islamabad High Court (IHC) has directed the petitioner in the Bari Imam House case to present documentary proof of ownership before the Capital Development Authority (CDA). The court has given him five days to submit the relevant records, while allowing the authority to proceed under the law otherwise.
The case concerns the sealing of Bari Imam House in Nurpur Shahan, located opposite the shrine of Bari Imam Sarkar. Justice Ayyaz Shaukat issued the judgment while disposing of a writ petition filed by Muhammad Akmal, caretaker of the premises.
However, the court declined to declare ownership or settle the disputed status of the property. Instead, it directed the CDA to examine the available documents and reach a decision through a proper legal process.
Why Did the CDA Seal Bari Imam House?
The CDA sealed the premises on October 30 during a joint operation with the district administration. The authority maintained that the property occupied government land acquired under Award No. 4/DC CDA/1963.
According to the CDA, compensation had already been paid to the original landowners. It also identified Khasras No. 435, 582, 591, 592 and 593 as part of the acquisition.
Furthermore, the authority stated that its official records contain no building registered under the name of “Bari Imam House”. It maintained that the shrine occupies different land across the road.
Those shrine-related properties fall under Khasras No. 277, 665, 677, 678, 679 and 680.
Petitioner Claims Property Was Exempted Shrine Land
Muhammad Akmal disputed the CDA’s position, claiming that the premises stood on exempted shrine property. He maintained that the land had never been acquired by the authority.
According to his petition, the property includes a mosque, a langar khana and facilities for wuzu (ablution). He also challenged the sealing operation, alleging that officials acted without issuing notice or providing an opportunity for a hearing.
The petitioner argued that the action violated several constitutional provisions. However, the court found that the ownership dispute involved contested factual questions.
Justice Ayyaz Shaukat observed that constitutional proceedings could not resolve such questions through unsupported claims. Moreover, the petitioner had failed to produce ownership documents.
His counsel also acknowledged that the relevant records remained with the CDA and Islamabad Capital Territory administration.
IHC Gives Petitioner Five Days to Submit Documents
The court directed the petitioner to present any available ownership documents before the CDA within five days. Subsequently, the authority must provide him with an opportunity for a hearing.
The CDA must examine the submitted documents alongside its own records. It must then issue a reasoned order within two days after the hearing.
However, if the petitioner fails to submit the documents or chooses not to do so, the CDA can proceed according to law.
During the proceedings, the petitioner’s counsel also acknowledged that Muhammad Akmal did not personally own the property. Instead, he served as its caretaker.
Meanwhile, CDA counsel Kashif Ali Malik challenged the petition’s maintainability and described the occupation as an encroachment on government land.
Previous IHC Order Merged Into Final Judgment
The court clarified that its interim order dated November 3 had merged into the final judgment. That earlier order had directed the premises’ de-sealing and restrained officials from carrying out any “demolition” until the next hearing.
Importantly, the latest judgment does not determine the ownership or possession rights of either party. Instead, it leaves the matter to the CDA’s document-based review.
The court also clarified that anyone dissatisfied with the authority’s decision can pursue the remedies available under the law.
Consequently, the final decision on Bari Imam House’s ownership remains dependent on the documentary evidence and the CDA’s determination.
For the latest updates, visit and follow The Truth International website (www.thetruthinternational.com) and subscribe to the YouTube Channel.
